Review: Rose Under Fire


Author: Elizabeth Wein
Date of Publication: September 10 2013
Pages: 368
Source: Library Ebook

While flying an Allied fighter plane from Paris to England, American ATA pilot and amateur poet, Rose Justice, is captured by the Nazis and sent to Ravensbrück, the notorious women's concentration camp. Trapped in horrific circumstances, Rose finds hope in the impossible through the loyalty, bravery and friendship of her fellow prisoners. But will that be enough to endure the fate that's in store for her?

Elizabeth Wein, author of the critically-acclaimed and best-selling Code Name Verity, delivers another stunning WWII thriller. The unforgettable story of Rose Justice is forged from heart-wrenching courage, resolve, and the slim, bright chance of survival.


Review:

I'm not the first, nor the last to write this, but Rose Under Fire didn't have the punch of Code Name Verity. It was more of a cold heartbreak, and the end, especially the author's note, furthered the point.

Rose Justice is a regular girl, except she comes from a reasonably well-off family and is a pilot. She has worked hard to get to England, and is actually friends with Maddie from Code Name Verity. She's someone relatable and I liked that she always had an American perspective on everything. There are so many nuances to every culture and Rose Under Fire really emphasized that in the war, there were only individuals doing what they could.

The topic is harsh and well written. Rose's time at camp almost felt sensationalized, and I shivered when I read that all of the major events she experienced were real. They occurred, and those women were tortured. Humanity's capacity for cruelty was horrifying to read about, but it was also heartbreaking to read that midst all the suffering, friendships and families were still being formed. No one would have thought less of those girls if they broke, but they kept going. Their strength was incredible.

World building wise, everything felt well researched and real. Rose's story resonated because it was the story of someone who went through something awful, and she was a normal girl. Rose wrote poetry, and it's a big part of her character. I can't say that I was the biggest fan of the poetry, mostly because I was so engrossed in the story, but some will enjoy the multiple writing styles.

Plot wise, the story was rather slow. It was about Rose's journey from regular ATA pilot to Ravensbruck and it was very heavy on the details. It's not the type of book I usually read, and Elizabeth Wein didn't try to make the story overly emotional. A theme in Rose Under Fire is tell the world, and that's what I felt the story was doing: being a testimony of what happened to Rose and the other girls when they were imprisoned in the camp.

The character development was good because all the characters were a little different. Obviously, Rose was the character best known and that's because what we were reading was her narration through her journal. Still, every character was distinctive. I especially liked that Rose Under Fire explored an area of the second world war that I haven't really read too much about, and I feel like I learned something about that world. The Jews weren't the only targets.

My enjoyment of the story is not as high as I want it to be, but it's worth considering that this isn't the type of story to enjoy. It's rather bleak. It's more of a learning experience. I didn't have the greatest emotional connection, and I did feel some parts were overwritten and the book could have been shortened. So for that, I have to give Rose Under Fire 3 stars because it was a good book.


-P.E.


15 comments:

  1. I have both Code Name Verity and Rose Under Fire on my TBR. I really like the sound of the character development plausible research when it came to the world building. The slow plot would have put me off though so I am glad you got through it anyway!

    Thanks for sharing lovely & great review! :D

    ps - replying to the comment on my blog, what uni are you going to & what are you studying? :) xx

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Code Name Verity is great because it attacks you emotionally, while Rose Under Fire is a lot like a really dull pain.

      I'm going to McGill and I'll be studying commerce, although most of my first year classes are politics electives. :)

      Thanks for visiting!

      -P.E.

      Delete
  2. I didn't have much luck with Verity, unfortunately. So this one is probably going to be a pass for me. Sorry you weren't able to enjoy it as much.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It is quite long in the beginning, so I've heard of others with the same opinion.

      -P.E.

      Delete
  3. My sister and I haven't read Wein's Code Name Verity yet, but we're hoping to real soon (once we get our review books out of the way). This sounds like an interesting companion book, though, and I'll definitely look out for it; the aspects that were good make it a read that I can't totally pass up.

    Thanks for the honest review and happy reading!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I think Rose Under Fire is a really important read and I would totally encourage people to read it. Enjoy Code Name Verity too!

      -P.E.

      Delete
  4. I have yet to read Code Name Verity, so I think I'll get to that one first and then maybe check this one out someday. Thanks for the honest review!

    Nicole @ Feed Your Fiction Addiction

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Code Name Verity is pretty great so I hope you enjoy it!

      -P.E.

      Delete
  5. I still haven't read Code Name Verity or Rose Under Fire, but I've heard so many great things about both!
    Bummer than you didn't connect more with the book emotionally, but at least it still was a good read for you.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You should definitely read them soon! I had different reactions to them, but they both are important books to read.

      -P.E.

      Delete
  6. LOL! You def aren't the first nor the last. I need to read CNV now that I have the free audio from audiosync. I'm gla you liked the writing. Well, aren't historicals mostly all rather slow on the plot? Sorry you felt like it was dragging and you didn't really get very emotional. Yay that you loved the characters though :) I'm glad you enjoyed as a whole!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I don't think they're all slow. I've read a few that were fast-paced, but I felt like this one was so well developed that if it was a steak, it could be a well done one? Whereas some people like medium? Rose Under Fire is a good book, so no wonder I enjoyed it.

      -P.E.

      Delete
  7. Hm. We ADORED Code Name Verity, but we're less certain about this one. Especially since Kristan just finished reading a book that was too much about research/method and not enough about story/character/emotion... (She blogged about that yesterday.) Thanks for sharing your thoughts!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I still think you guys should give this one a read. It's a quieter story, which isn't a bad thing for everyone. And in regards to the research, I think it was well balanced all throughout.

      -P.E.

      Delete
  8. Rajasthan Sr Secondary Model Paper 2022 Students only have to Download the Rajasthan Board 12th Mock Test Paper 2021 for all the important subjects are available BSER 12th Model Paper 2022 Including the Hindi, English, Sanskrit, Mathematics, Geography, History, Drawing, Polity_Sci, Grah Vigyan, Chemistry, Physics, Accountancy, Arthshastra, Computer, Manovigyan, Samajshastra, Sangeet etc. Rajasthan Board 12th Model Paper 2021 has announced Government Board of School Education, RBSE Students who are going to sit in Public Examination 2021 are allowed to Download Rajasthan Board 12th Sample Paper 2021 Download our web Portal.

    ReplyDelete

What do you think?